The Arizona Statute of Limitations Applicable to Collection Lawsuits and Non-Judicial Trustee’s Foreclosure Sales of Real Property, article by Larry O. Folks, Folks Hess, PLLC (1/2021).

Excerpts:

  1. Can a lender collect upon a promissory note that matured six or more years ago?

Short answer: No. The statute of limitations applies to each matured/defaulted note installment payment separately as it becomes due under the note amortization schedule, and it does not begin to run on any installment until it is due. Andra R. Miller Designs LLC v. US Bank NA, 244 Ariz. 265, 270, 418 P.3d 1038, 1043 (App.  2018)  review denied (July 3, 2018). See also, Ancala Holdings L.L.C.  v.  Price, 220 Fed.  App.  569, 572 (9th Cir. 2007) (a cause of action “accrues” each time a party fails to perform as required by the contract) and Ortiz v. Trinity Fin. Servs. LLC, 98 F.Supp. 3d 1037, 1042 (D. Ariz. 2015) (each time the debtor fails to make a payment when it becomes due, a separate breach occurs and a cause of action “accrues”, starting the clock).

Because the maturity date of a promissory note is the last scheduled installment payment of the debt instrument, the cause of action for that final installment payment “accrues” on the loan maturity date.  As a result, a lender cannot sue upon the promissory note six years or more after the scheduled maturity date.

EXAMPLE: Loan Maturity Date:  1/1/2015. Current Date: 1/2/2021. A Collection Lawsuit or Foreclosure Sale is barred, as more than six years have passed since the loan maturity date.

7.   Application of the six-year statute of limitations to loans that have not been accelerated:

When does a cause of action “accrue” upon a defaulted unmatured installment promissory note for the purpose of calculating the six-year statute of limitation if the lender has not taken an affirmative act to accelerate the loan?

Short answer: The statute of limitations applies to each matured/defaulted Note installment payment separately as it becomes due under the Note amortization schedule, and does not begin to run on any installment until it is due.

If the creditor does not exercise the option to accelerate an installment contract debt and/or to determine the date of “accrual” of a cause of action upon a matured/defaulted monthly installment payment, the statute of limitations applies to each matured/defaulted Note installment payment separately as it becomes due under the Note amortization schedule, and does not begin to run on any installment until it is due. Andra R. Miller Designs LLC v. US Bank NA, 244 Ariz. 265, 270, 418 P.3d 1038, 1043 (App.  2018)  review denied (July 3, 2018). See also, Ancala Holdings L.L.C.  v. Price, 220 Fed.  App.  569, 572 (9th Cir. 2007) (a cause of action “accrues” each time a party fails to perform as required by the contract) and Ortiz v. Trinity Fin. Servs. LLC, 98 F.Supp. 3d 1037, 1042 (D. Ariz. 2015) (each time the debtor fails to make a payment when it becomes due, a separate breach occurs and a cause of action “accrues,” starting the clock).

The rules discussed above concerning deter- mining the date of “accrual” of a cause of action based upon a defaulted mortgage loan installment promissory note have been applied consistently by the Arizona Court of Appeals and the United States District Court for the District of Arizona in the following line of cases: Andra R. Miller Designs LLC v. US Bank NA, 244 Ariz. 265, 418 P.3d 1038 (AZ App. 2018) review denied (July 3, 2018).  Baseline Financial Services v.  Madison, 229 Ariz. 543, 278 P.3d 321 (AZ App. 2012); Navy Federal Credit Union v. Jones, 187 Ariz. 493, 930 P.2d 1007 (AZ App. 1996); Hummel v. Rushmore Loan Management LLC, 2018 WL 3744858 (D. AZ 2018); and Ortiz v. Trinity Financial Services LLC, 98 F.Supp.3d 1037 (D. AZ. 2015). Furthermore, as was fully discussed above, the Arizona Supreme Court, in Mertola, LLC v. Santos, 244 Ariz. 488, 490, 796 Ariz. Adv. Rep. 16, 422 P.3d 1028, 1030 (2018) distinguished installment debt from credit card debt in the context of selecting the correct rules to determine when a cause of action “accrues” to calculate the six-year statute of limitation.

EXAMPLE #1: Loan Maturity Date: 1/1/21. Last Payment: 1/1/15. Current Date: 1/2/21. Both a Collection Lawsuit and a Foreclosure Sale are barred.

EXAMPLE #2: Loan Date: 1/1/10. Loan Maturity Date:   1/1/40.   Loan   is   not   accelerated.   Last Payment Made: 1/1/15. Current Date: 1/2/21. The limitations period bars a suit on any payments due under the loan on 1/1/15 or earlier. The lender may, however, still commence a Collection Lawsuit or Foreclosure Sale based upon the installment payments due from 2/1/15 going forward.

  1. Do the same rules apply to determine when a cause of action “accrues” to pursue a

non-judicial Foreclosure Sale of real property as apply to a matured or unmatured installment promissory note?

Short answer: Yes.

See, Andra R. Miller Designs LLC v. US Bank, 244 Ariz. 265, 269, 418 P.3d 1038, 1042 (AZ Ct. App. 2018), review denied (July 3, 2018).

MUSINGS BY DIANE:

knowledge

My favorite client, or prospective client, is someone who wants to learn as much as possible about their situation, so they can make informed decisions. Finances are confusing and everyone needs to take time to determine the best way to find a solution that works in the long run, not just today. Never rely on the Internet for advice – there is more bad advice than good. Always seek advice from at least two people who are experienced in the area you need help. Once armed with good information, then use your common sense to decide what is best for you.

– Diane L. Drain
932 words|4.8 min read|Categories: Collection companies & Debt buyers, Creditors Rights, Debt Relief Agencies, Foreclosure, Trustee Sale and Foreclosure Videos|By |Published On: January 30th, 2021|Last Updated: July 25th, 2022|

Share this article

Diane is a well respected Arizona bankruptcy and foreclosure attorney. As a retired law professor, she believes in offering everyone, not just her clients, advice about bankruptcy and Arizona foreclosure laws. Diane is also a mentor to hundreds of Arizona attorneys.

*Important Note from Diane: Everything on this web site is offered for educational purposes only and not intended to provide legal advice, nor create an attorney client relationship between you, me, or the author of any article. Information in this web site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from an attorney familiar with your personal circumstances and licensed to practice law in your state. Make sure to check out their reviews.*

Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Google Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Yelp Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Avvo Reviews
Avvo - Rate your Lawyer. Get Free Legal Advice.
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Alignable Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Better Business Bureau
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Google Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Yelp Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Avvo Reviews
Avvo - Rate your Lawyer. Get Free Legal Advice.
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Alignable Reviews
Law Office of D.L. Drain, P.A., Arizona Bankruptcy Lawyer - Better Business Bureau

In Case You Missed It

  • Want to avoid dishonest debt collectors? Watch this video from FTC’s Consumer Advice By Joseph Ferrari,July 22, 2022 (reprint from FTC, Consumer Alerts) During Military Consumer Month 2022, the FTC is highlighting resources [...]

  • WHAT HAPPENS AT THE END OF A COVID-19 FORECLOSURE FORBEARANCE? Can servicers demand a large balance? Generally, the servicers should not be demanding full payment following a COVID forbearance. There [...]

  • Published On: January 20, 2022

    Bankruptcy Issues After January 1, 2022 Changes in Arizona Homestead Statutes Reprint from Gary Stickell’s website: January 19, 2022 The Arizona Homestead exemption increased from $150,000 to $250,000 as of [...]

  • Published On: October 25, 2021

    CFPB Confirms Effective Date for Debt Collection Final Rules (Reprint from CFPB, July 30, 2021) The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) today announced two final rules under the FDCPA will [...]