bible on layoff notice

Does God Want You to Be Bankrupt?

By RON LIEBER, New York Times, Published: May 1, 2009 (provided here solely for educational purposes).

This week, yet another Washington debate over who deserves a break on their debts drew to a close. On Thursday, the Senate voted against allowing judges to adjust the terms of the mortgages of people filing for personal bankruptcy.

Skip to the next paragraph and scratch the surface of the opposition in these sorts of debates, and it tends to ooze moral righteousness. “People who get themselves in over their heads,” the upstanding declare, “need to bear some responsibility for their foolishness.” Maybe so. But if we can’t pass legislation that gives us new tools to determine who should be eligible for debt forgiveness, we need to look elsewhere for written instruction. Given that large numbers of Americans take many of their moral cues from their spiritual beliefs, I decided to turn to the good books of some of the world’s great religions for guidance on the subject.

Just about every doctrinal expert I spoke with, no matter the background, began by mentioning slavery.

In ancient times, when interest accrued and compounded, it was common for the indebted to simply work it off. Often, this took the rest of their lives. Many of the teachings that grew up around debt forgiveness aimed to avoid that sort of outcome.

Still, the notion of enslavement, albeit of the psychological sort, survived to modern times.

N. Eldon Tanner, a leader of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, wrote: “Those who structure their standard of living to allow a little surplus control their circumstances. Those who spend a little more than they earn are controlled by their circumstances. They are in bondage.”

This will be a familiar idea to people who have considered the idea of paying only the minimum amount on a large credit card debt, only to realize that if they do that, the debt may actually outlive them. “Binding oneself financially is not something that trumps every other need,” added the Rev. Brian Daley, a Jesuit priest and professor of theology at the University of Notre Dame. Scripture suggests that the redistribution of property is also a reasonable thing to do. “You just can’t mention it in public in the United States,” he said. “Our notion of capitalism is so absolutized that we give it a quasi-religious value.”

However strongly we believe in free markets (not, perhaps, as fervently as we did a year or two ago), the theme of forgiveness does run strongly through religious writings of all sorts.

Book of Deuteronomy - 15In the Old Testament, for instance, Chapter 15 of the book of Deuteronomy calls for the forgiveness of debts once every seven years. Religious leaders were aware, however, of the chilling effect that could have on lending (particularly in the sixth year). “The Torah says don’t think that way, don’t be stingy” in that sixth year, said Rabbi Mark Washofsky, a professor of Jewish law at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in Cincinnati. He added that later on, the Talmud introduced the idea of a Prosbul. This was a sort of workaround court that was not covered by the religious law. The Prosbul could administer debts during or right before the seventh year.

When the court confiscated property outright, sometimes this worked to the benefit of the debtor and sometimes to the benefit of the creditor.

“In other words, the ultimate power resides with the community,” Rabbi Washofsky said. “It can intervene in what was a private transaction, in a situation of great need. The power is there. The real question is, do you use it and when?” The answer depends on who you are ultimately reporting to, your immediate supervisor, your shareholders or the Entity that will ultimately render judgment on you.

Picture of Father Daley, Notre Dame

Father Daley

Father Daley, of Notre Dame, said that the New Testament talked about debts to God resulting from sin. Another idea popular with rabbis and early Christians, he said, was the notion that doing good deeds turned God into a debtor. “God is a kind of referee or bookkeeper, noticing things that people do,” he said. “And if they do good deeds without obligation, God will repay them in judgment. I think being able to dismiss debts or forgive them is something that is seen as a generous and gracious act.”

Bankers that cater to Muslims, who are not allowed to charge interest

This is because of some of the tenets of Islamic law, claim to foreclose on homeowners less frequently than regular creditors, according to Mahmoud Amin El-Gamal, an expert on Islamic finance and an economics professor at Rice University. He added, however, that any leniency was probably priced into the financing in the first place, making it a bit more expensive. The Koran, meanwhile, offers one of the more useful ideas on debt. “If the debtor is in a difficulty, grant him time till it is easy for him to repay,” the passage in the second chapter, verse 280, reads. “But if ye remit by way of charity, that is best for you if ye only knew.” Charity is not required here, according to Mr. El-Gamal. But during that granting of time, he added, the creditor is not allowed to charge interest.

This offers a possible compromise.

If lenders and senators are unwilling to allow judges to permanently alter the terms of a mortgage loan, perhaps they would agree to allow qualified borrowers who have lost their jobs or fallen ill to take a two- to six-month break from making payments. During this time, the lenders would stop the interest clock from ticking, not levy any fees and not tack on missed payments to the end of the loan. Then, once the borrowers were back on their feet, they could start regular payments again. If they weren’t able to make them by then, then foreclosure proceedings could begin.

Or, if this proves unpalatable or too expensive, how about selling an insurance policy that would pay for a six-month period of payments? That could satisfy both God and the gods of capitalism.

Perhaps if the Democrats want to enact bankruptcy reform, they ought to bring an imam to address their opponents.

How could anyone believe that it is a sin to file for bankruptcy?

bible on layoff noticeIn Ancient Greece, bankruptcy did not exist. If a man owed and he could not pay, he and his wife, children or servants were forced into “debt slavery”, until the creditor was paid via their physical labor.  Later a debtor could get a fresh start, but only after giving to his creditors everything he owned except some bare necessities.  Then the English established debtor’s prison, the bankrupt was seen as being bonded to his creditors and would be released from jail only if he had assets that did not exceed £20, but if any of their creditors objected, they had to stay inside. Voluntary bankruptcy did not become law in Britain until 1849.  But 60 years earlier, in 1789 the United States Constitution gave the power to Congress to legislate “uniform laws on the subject of Bankruptcies”. Congress’ first law was the Bankruptcy Act of 1800, which was involuntarily and only limited to traders.  The Bankruptcy Act of 1938 expanded voluntary access to the bankruptcy system, and voluntary petitions were made more attractive to debtors.

The point is that people require help in resolving burdensome debts, many of which were not their fault.  Why do I say that ? Because the four most common causes of bankruptcy are medical, unemployment, divorce, or death. None of these were choices for the debtor. Life happened, as it does to all of us. Some of us are more fortunate than others.

When you hear that someone is thinking about filing for bankruptcy, don’t jump to conclusions. The alternative may be a lifetime of buying high-interest vehicles, having wages garnished, and having to borrow high-interest payday loans in order to feed the family. It’s a never-ending cycle.

Published On: June 13th, 2022By Categories: Bankruptcy - History & ReligionComments Off on Is Bankruptcy a Sin?Tags:

Share This post, Choose Your social network!

Diane is a well respected Arizona bankruptcy and foreclosure attorney. As a retired law professor, she believes in offering everyone, not just her clients, advice about bankruptcy and Arizona foreclosure laws. Diane is also a mentor to hundreds of Arizona attorneys. *Important Note from Diane: Everything on this web site is offered for educational purposes only and not intended to provide legal advice, nor create an attorney client relationship between you, me, or the author of any article. Information in this web site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from an attorney familiar with your personal circumstances and licensed to practice law in your state. Make sure to check out their reviews.*